continue shopping Shopping Cart (0)
  • + -
  • Cart is empty
Desserts, Drinks and Cocktails, Party

Harry Potter's Butterbeer Shake

Stuffed Puffs® Harry Potter Butterbeer

This butterbeer recipe in honor of Harry's birthday is spell inducing. It's rich, delicious and a magical treat you should enjoy while watching the latest Quidditch match (or for muggles, by watching the series over and over). Now, if you'll excuse us we have to go practice our Expelliarmus.

Prep Time Servings
15 minutes 6-8 servings



  1. In a blender, combine 3 Stuffed Puffs® Filled Marshmallows, cream soda, vanilla ice cream, butterscotch pudding mix, heavy cream, vanilla, and ice cubes. Blend until mixture thickens.
  2. Pour shake into cup.
  3. Top off drink with 4 toasted Stuffed Puffs®.
  4. Drizzle butterscotch sauce as desired.

You May Also Like

Caramelized Banana S'more Caramelized Banana S'more
Desserts, Party, S'mores
Choco Cherry Pie S'more Choco Cherry Pie S'more
Desserts, Party, S'mores
Boozy S'mores Boozy S'mores
Drinks and Cocktails, S'mores